I finally watched Al Gore's documentary - "An Inconvenient Truth" - a few weeks ago.
In the interest of full disclosure, if you don't already know, I'm a registered Republican. I also have a B.S. in Environmental Science, which included an internship (and a follow-on part-time position) with an 8(a) minority-owned environmental consulting firm. My father started the Environmental Management office at one of the US's largest military bases, and then went on to become the site manager at a Superfund site.
My point? Conservative thinkers are not necessarily anti-environment.
But environmental hysteria does not impress me. Likewise, callous dismissal of evidence as mere "hysteria" doesn't impress me either. Objective scientific research, presented in a thoughtful manner - that's what gets my attention.
I was surprised to find that I really enjoyed this documentary - well, apart from being a bit disconcerted by some of the evidence presented. I've never thought Al Gore was an engaging speaker, but he held my attention throughout the environmental discussions. I could have done without his personal vignettes, which really added very little to the topic.
But while I took away some new information from the film, I also kept in mind that the environment is Al Gore's passion (sloppy kisses at political conventions aside). It's in his interest to present evidence that supports his conclusions. After alll, the man is a lawyer.
I've since done more investigation and found some critical analysis of "An Inconvenient Truth". The Competitive Enterprise Institute published "A Skeptic's Guide to An Inconvenient Truth". I haven't yet read the entire document, but the executive summary has piqued my curiosity.
I'm curious NOT because I want to prove Al Gore wrong or discredit his claims. I'm curious because that's how we LEARN. If you take the word of one source - be it Al Gore or President Bush or a nightly television news anchor - as the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth - you will come away no wiser, regardless of your political leanings.
As always, my plea to all people - soccer moms or not - is to take a second look at all issues. I took a second look when I watched this film, and I'm taking a third look by reading the CEI response. But I can't stop there; I need to keep reading, keep learning, taking new information into consideration. We all do.
Recent Comments